Has Post Office wrongly claimed tax relief for compensation?
It’s been widely reported that the Post Office wasn’t entitled to tax relief for compensation it expects to pay to sub-postmasters. If that’s the case, might you be in trouble with HMRC if you’ve ever claimed relief for compensation paid to a customer?
Disputed tax relief
If you watched the recent TV drama you probably won’t need reminding about facts in the Post Office (PO) debacle. Subsequently, a tax expert has argued that the PO isn’t entitled to the tax relief it claimed for the cost of prosecuting the sub-postmasters or for the compensation it now expects to pay. This opinion was picked up by the media and has gained a lot of traction. If the tax expert’s view is correct many business owners will now be worried about the tax treatment of compensation payments they have or will make. In this article we explain when tax relief is and isn’t allowed for compensation payments using the PO case as an example.
Prosecuting fraudsters
In his statement the tax expert says that the PO was not entitled to a tax deduction for the cost of prosecuting sub-postmasters it believed were guilty of fraud or theft. Hundreds of sub-postmasters were found guilty and some went to prison.
Subsequent events culminating in a judgment in 2019 exonerated many sub-postmasters and many if not all of the original judgments are likely to be overturned. Regardless, in our view the PO was entitled to a tax deduction for the cost of identifying fraud against it and recouping income it believed had been stolen.
Costs incurred in the course of trade by a business to protect or recover its income, whether through the courts or by other means as long as they aren’t unlawful or illegal, are tax deductible.
Compensation payments
The tax expert also claimed that the PO wasn’t entitled to tax relief for a “provision” included in its accounts for the cost of compensation payable to sub-postmasters. Broadly, a provision for an expense is an amount that hasn’t been paid but is a current liability. It was suggested that the PO was being investigated by HMRC about the tax deductibility of the provision. The tax expert said the compensation was paid by the PO because of its wrongdoing which affected sub-postmasters.
The tax expert’s suggestion that because the compensation is for wrongdoing it’s not tax deductible isn’t logical. Wrongdoing by one party to another is the foundation of compensation. The correct test for tax deductibility is that compensation must be paid in the course of and for the purpose of a business’s trade.
Example. A business pays a customer compensation because its delivery van damaged the customer’s property. The compensation might consist of two elements: the cost of repairing the damage and payment for distress caused to the customer - a goodwill payment. Tax relief for the compensation for the repair is OK as is the goodwill payment as long as there’s a commercial reason for it. This is not to say that in the PO case there might be different reasons why HMRC would challenge the tax deduction. HMRC’s guidance says a “compensation payment incurred in the normal course of trading relates, for instance, to a trading contract will be an allowable deduction. ”
Related Topics
-
Mixing business travel with pleasure
Our subscriber’s employee is opening a new branch three hours away from home. The employee has asked if her husband can join her at the weekend while she visits. Does this private purpose mean that any part of the travel and accommodation expenses is taxable?
-
Will new property tax rates erode tax efficiency?
You recently purchased a new trading premises for your business and plan to charge your company rent. As tax rates on property income are going up in April 2027, is this arrangement likely to be tax efficient?
-
MTD taxpayers warned to check two accounts for tax bills
Taxpayers who joined Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax in April 2026 are being warned that their tax payment information may be split between two separate HMRC accounts. With the January Self Assessment deadline approaching, could you be overlooking part of your tax bill?