Court of Appeal rules in contractors' favour
A TV presenter won a high-profile Upper Tribunal case regarding her employment status under the IR35 rules. HMRC appealed against this, but the Court of Appeal has just rejected its argument. What happened?
HMRC’s argument was that the Upper Tribunal had interpreted a key piece of case law incorrectly. The case in question sets out the factors that should be considered, such as mutuality of obligation, personal service and others. HMRC argued that whether someone is “in business on their own account” (i.e. other factors) should be given little weight, and even argued that considering this would be an onerous compliance burden for HMRC. In a decision published today, the Court of Appeal unanimously rejected this argument, stating that circumstances known to both parties at the date of the contract, e.g. the fact that the person providing the work has an established career as a freelance worker, should be taken into account. This is a huge win for all contractors, particularly those providing personal services.
The decision on whether, overall, there would have existed an employment relationship in this case was remitted back to the Upper Tribunal.
Related Topics
-
Mixing business travel with pleasure
Our subscriber’s employee is opening a new branch three hours away from home. The employee has asked if her husband can join her at the weekend while she visits. Does this private purpose mean that any part of the travel and accommodation expenses is taxable?
-
How should you rent out surplus space at your premises?
An increase in homeworking by your staff means you have surplus space in your office that could be rented out. Should you rent out a room or clearly defined area to tenants or let them use unoccupied rooms on an ad hoc basis?
-
MTD taxpayers warned to check two accounts for tax bills
Taxpayers who joined Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax in April 2026 are being warned that their tax payment information may be split between two separate HMRC accounts. With the January Self Assessment deadline approaching, could you be overlooking part of your tax bill?